Spiritual and Moral Theory & Psycho-analytic Theory of Addiction
Spirituality is an important concept for many people. This is particularly true for people struggling to recover from severe or fatal disorders such as addiction.
In Western Judeo-Christian cultures such as the United States, spiritual models typically presume a God with supernatural powers. This God is seen as one who governs, guides, directs, or intervenes on behalf of human beings. Spiritual models assume addiction occurs because of a separation from God. Moral causes of addiction presume there is a "correct" morality based on a particular set of values. Deviation from those values results in addiction. It is important to note that moral codes reflect the value system of a particular culture.
Therefore, the "correct" moral code will vary from one culture to the next. According to the spiritual model, a disconnection from God or a Higher Power causes addiction. This separation causes people's suffering because they fail to live according to God's will or direction. Therefore, recovery consists of establishing or re-establishing a connection with God or a Higher Power. The most prominent example of the spiritual approach is Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) and other 12-step groups. Participants practice 12-steps. These 12-steps help people restore their spiritual connection with a higher power. There are also "faith-based" approaches that arise from specific religious orientations.
Prayer, meditation, and counseling with spiritual advisors are techniques associated with this model. Questions for personal reflection from the spiritual model:
How do I evaluate my life in terms of my relationship with God or a Higher Power?
How do I evaluate my life in terms of my own ultimate values and beliefs?
Am I living in accordance with what I believe is important?
Do I devote enough time reflecting upon my values and believes?
According to the Moral model, a moral failure- a failure to do what is right causes addiction. Therefore, recovery consists of strengthening one's will or motivation to behave in an upright manner. The moral model is prominent in traditional approaches to recovery. "He just needs to strengthen his willpower to resist temptation and get on with his life." The criminal justice system also approaches addiction from this perspective.
Punishments for addiction related crimes (e.g., DUI, public intoxication) are intended to motivate people to behave better. Trying to persuade someone to behave better is also a technique associated with this model. Moral Reconation Therapy (MRT) is an evidence-based addiction treatment aligned with this model, but MRT is not well known. Conation is an archaic psychological term referring to our capacity for conscious and deliberate decision-making.
Moral Reconation Therapy works to raise the moral level of decision-making. Questions for personal reflection from the moral model:
Aren't there times when I need to exert more effort and willpower to stay on track?
Should I use willpower to behave better make wiser choices?
Are there times when I need to exert more effort to do the things, I know will help me in my recovery efforts? I know if I make the extra effort to exercise every day, I feel better. This improved my mood. It also reduced my cravings and made it easier for me to resist them.
Psycho-analytic Theory of Addiction
Psychoanalysis is considered as a theory, a treatment, and a way of thinking about human motivation. A psychoanalytic perspective includes conscious and repressed, unconscious motives and desires. Psychoanalysis is traditionally conceived as an opportunity for a motivated person to reflect deeply about everything he or she is feeling and thinking without editing or censoring.
Addiction is described as a defensive strategy to avoid feeling of helplessness or powerlessness. Drug abuse is a futile attempt to compensate for inner emptiness without success. The addict tries to compensate via addictive behavior for painful subjective states of low self-esteem, doubts, and anxiety. The use of drugs supplies a feeling of acceptance and temporary self-confidence. An addict substitutes an imaginary world, where he is in complete control, for the real world, where he feels useless and out of control. Repeated use of drugs to gain relief becomes a way of life. Relief is momentary, but in the long-term, drug use becomes an end in itself. The addiction problem prevents the user from understanding her distress, as well as the development of an emotional capacity to self-soothe.
The psychoanalytic view suggests addiction is basically a disorder of self-regulation. For instance, individuals with histories of exposure to adverse childhood environments like physical and sexual abuse tend to have a diminished capacity to regulate negative emotions and cope effectively with stress. These individuals may be self-medicating anxiety and mood disorders.
It is instructive to note that many individuals experiment with drugs but few become addicted. The success of therapy and the lasting change require the patients come into contact with previously inaccessible aspects of their inner feelings. Helping patients increase their ability to engage in self-reflection and identify alternative ways to manage difficult emotions are part of the psychodynamic approach to addiction treatment.
Our Standard Review
Date created: 16 Aug 2024 06:10:42
Critical Evaluation:
The article presents a thoughtful exploration of spirituality and addiction recovery, particularly within Western Judeo-Christian contexts. The arguments are coherent and logically structured, outlining how spiritual disconnection is linked to addiction. However, the article could strengthen its claims by incorporating empirical evidence or studies that demonstrate the effectiveness of spiritual models in addiction recovery.
While the article acknowledges the variability of moral codes across cultures, it does not sufficiently address how these differences impact addiction treatment. This oversight could lead to a narrow understanding of addiction that does not account for diverse cultural perspectives. The article appears to maintain a neutral tone, but it may inadvertently favor spiritual and moral models over others, such as medical or psychological approaches. This bias could limit the reader's understanding of the multifaceted nature of addiction. The implications of these ideas suggest that recovery is deeply personal and may require a tailored approach that considers individual beliefs and cultural backgrounds.
Quality of Information:
The language used in the article is generally accessible, making it easy for a broad audience to understand. However, some technical terms, such as "conation" and "Moral Reconation Therapy," could benefit from clearer explanations for readers unfamiliar with psychological jargon. The information presented appears accurate and reliable, drawing on established theories of addiction. There are no evident signs of misinformation or logical fallacies, and the article adheres to ethical standards in discussing sensitive topics like addiction.
The article introduces new ideas, particularly in its exploration of the psychoanalytic perspective on addiction, which adds depth to the discussion. However, it could enhance its value by providing more context or examples of how these theories are applied in real-world scenarios.
Use of Evidence and References:
The article references well-known models and therapies, such as Alcoholics Anonymous and Moral Reconation Therapy, which lend credibility to its claims. However, it lacks specific citations or references to studies that support the effectiveness of these approaches. This absence creates gaps in the evidence, leaving some assertions unsubstantiated. The article would benefit from integrating research findings or expert opinions to bolster its arguments and provide a more comprehensive view of the subject matter.
Further Research and References:
Further exploration could focus on the effectiveness of integrating spiritual, moral, and psychological approaches in addiction treatment. Research could also investigate how cultural differences influence perceptions of addiction and recovery.
Potential sources for additional reading might include:
- Studies on the efficacy of spiritual approaches in addiction recovery.
- Literature on the role of cultural values in shaping addiction treatment.
- Research on the psychological aspects of addiction and recovery.
Questions for Further Research:
- How do different cultural beliefs about spirituality influence addiction recovery?
- What role does community support play in the effectiveness of spiritual models for recovery?
- How can addiction treatment programs integrate multiple approaches (spiritual, moral, psychological) effectively?
- What empirical evidence exists to support the claims made by the spiritual and moral models of addiction?
- How does childhood trauma impact the likelihood of developing an addiction?
- What are the long-term outcomes for individuals who use spiritual approaches compared to those who use psychological therapies?
- How do personal values and beliefs shape an individual's approach to recovery?
- What are the challenges faced by individuals who do not identify with traditional spiritual or moral frameworks in recovery?
- How can therapists help clients access repressed emotions related to addiction?
- What new therapeutic models are emerging in the field of addiction treatment?
Rate This Post
Rate The Educational Value
Rate The Ease of Understanding and Presentation
Interesting or Boring? Rate the Entertainment Value